Ask Laura: Coaching Myself is No Longer Working
15 Aug
From time to time, Ask Laura answers a question from readers. Got a question? You can submit it here.
Dear Laura,
I tend to try and coach myself, which is never very successful. I’ve got a stubborn do-it-myself mentality that makes it difficult to think about forming a formal coaching relationship. But I’m basically at a point where I can’t keep coaching myself because it obviously isn’t working. Do you have any suggestions on how to challenge this and call my own stubborn bluff?
-Stubborn and Independent
Dear Stubborn and Independent,
You have two qualities I love, and two qualities I share with you. I find stubborn independent streaks pretty charming, and I look back on all the things that I’ve been able to do in my life because I was stubborn and independent. Those qualities can be great gifts!
On the other hand, you’re also noticing that your stubborn independence has brought you to a point where “it obviously isn’t working,” so let’s take a look at that.
(I want to make clear that there’s no rule that you have to work with a coach. Many people will choose to decide that coaching is not for them, and I trust that decision. However, you’re curious (and resistant!) about the idea of a formal coaching relationship, so I’m going to ask you a few questions about that.)
Self-Coaching – Successful or Not?
You say that coaching yourself is not very successful. I invite you to pause and ask yourself, “Is that true?”
- In what ways is it true or not true?
- In what areas is coaching yourself working? Great — you don’t need to work with someone else on those areas.
- In what areas is self-coaching not working? Would you be open to speaking with someone else about those areas?
My own experience is that coaching myself is helpful, and that I function better, do more, and feel more on track overall when I’m working with a coach. In a nice symmetry, working with a coach keeps taking me further, so I get better and better at coaching myself, and I’m always being pushed. It’s like an upward spiral for me. (I’ve written previously about self-coaching.)
On Being “Stubborn” and How to Challenge It
So, if you DO think coaching is for you, but you’re still finding you’re resistant, then that’s where the coaching starts–with your resistance. A coach can prompt you to look at what your resistance is about, where it comes from, and why it’s important to you.
Some coach-like questions you might want to ask yourself:
- What do I believe will happen if I don’t do it myself?
- What do I believe it says about me if I ask for support from someone else?
- Is there a pattern here? Does this do-it-myself / stubborn theme only apply to coaching, or is it a theme in my life? If it is a theme: how has it helped me, and how has it held me back?
What Is It That You Want?
Finally, I offer you the classic coach question: What is it that you want?
And: Are you getting what you want with what you’re doing now?
And: If not, are you willing to try something new in order to get what you want?
If you are willing, then perhaps it’s time to contact a coach and see what might happen. And if you’re not, then I trust you to find something else that better supports you in reaching your goals.
*
Laura McGrath is an Ottawa-based life coach and therapist who works with clients all over the world. If you’re considering how working with a coach might be useful for you, she is more than happy to pick up the phone and have a conversation. Get in touch.
Like what you’re reading? There’s more where that came from!
I’d love to have you join me by signing up for Ready for Change news.

