Ask Laura: Coaching Myself is No Longer Working
15 Aug
From time to time, Ask Laura answers a question from readers. Got a question? You can submit it here.
Dear Laura,
I tend to try and coach myself, which is never very successful. I’ve got a stubborn do-it-myself mentality that makes it difficult to think about forming a formal coaching relationship. But I’m basically at a point where I can’t keep coaching myself because it obviously isn’t working. Do you have any suggestions on how to challenge this and call my own stubborn bluff?
-Stubborn and Independent
Dear Stubborn and Independent,
You have two qualities I love, and two qualities I share with you. I find stubborn independent streaks pretty charming, and I look back on all the things that I’ve been able to do in my life because I was stubborn and independent. Those qualities can be great gifts!
On the other hand, you’re also noticing that your stubborn independence has brought you to a point where “it obviously isn’t working,” so let’s take a look at that.
(I want to make clear that there’s no rule that you have to work with a coach. Many people will choose to decide that coaching is not for them, and I trust that decision. However, you’re curious (and resistant!) about the idea of a formal coaching relationship, so I’m going to ask you a few questions about that.)
Self-Coaching – Successful or Not?
You say that coaching yourself is not very successful. I invite you to pause and ask yourself, “Is that true?”
- In what ways is it true or not true?
- In what areas is coaching yourself working? Great — you don’t need to work with someone else on those areas.
- In what areas is self-coaching not working? Would you be open to speaking with someone else about those areas?
My own experience is that coaching myself is helpful, and that I function better, do more, and feel more on track overall when I’m working with a coach. In a nice symmetry, working with a coach keeps taking me further, so I get better and better at coaching myself, and I’m always being pushed. It’s like an upward spiral for me. (I’ve written previously about self-coaching.)
On Being “Stubborn” and How to Challenge It
So, if you DO think coaching is for you, but you’re still finding you’re resistant, then that’s where the coaching starts–with your resistance. A coach can prompt you to look at what your resistance is about, where it comes from, and why it’s important to you.
Some coach-like questions you might want to ask yourself:
- What do I believe will happen if I don’t do it myself?
- What do I believe it says about me if I ask for support from someone else?
- Is there a pattern here? Does this do-it-myself / stubborn theme only apply to coaching, or is it a theme in my life? If it is a theme: how has it helped me, and how has it held me back?
What Is It That You Want?
Finally, I offer you the classic coach question: What is it that you want?
And: Are you getting what you want with what you’re doing now?
And: If not, are you willing to try something new in order to get what you want?
If you are willing, then perhaps it’s time to contact a coach and see what might happen. And if you’re not, then I trust you to find something else that better supports you in reaching your goals.
*
Laura McGrath is an Ottawa-based life coach and therapist who works with clients all over the world. If you’re considering how working with a coach might be useful for you, she is more than happy to pick up the phone and have a conversation. Get in touch.
Like what you’re reading? There’s more where that came from!
I’d love to have you join me by signing up for Ready for Change news.
Sign up here.

